Institute for Enterprise Ethics
LinkedIn YouTube Facebook The Discussion - IEE Blog
Institute for Enterprise Ethics The Discussion
The Discussion

The Discussion

Skip Navigation Links.

How Wall Street Bent Steel

Dec 11

Written by:
12/11/2014 11:19 AM  RssIcon

By Dan Sweeney
Director, Institute for Enterprise Ethics

Institute for Enterprise Ethics | How Wall Street Bent SteelOn Sunday, December 7, the New York Times ran a lengthy article with the above mentioned title detailing how an activist investor forced a publicly traded but family dominated steel company to split up into two public companies and put an entire city at risk. The board said they had no choice because “If the number is big enough the board is going to have to look at it and say ‘Ugh, OK….’ We are a publicly traded company.”

Nelson Schwartz, the author of the article went on to say “As in all publicly traded companies Timken Steel’s board and top executives have a fiduciary duty to shareholders to maximize both profits and investor  returns.” 

But this is not so. According to Lynn Stout, the Distinguished Professor of Corporate and Busness Law at Cornell Law School in her book The Shareholder Value Myth. Neither Federal law, State codes and statutes or state case law contain any provisions mandating the primacy of shareholder value over any other goal of a corporation.

“The notion that corporate law requires directors, executives, and employees to maximize shareholder wealth simply isn’t true. The idea is a fable.” (p. 24)


“Judges may say different things about what the public corporation’s purpose may be, but they uniformly refuse to actually impose legal sanctions on directors or executives for failing to pursue one purpose over another. In particular, courts refuse to hold directors of public corporations legally accountable for failing to maximize shareholder wealth.” (P.29)


“As far as the law is concerned, maximizing shareholder value is not a requirement; it is just one possible corporate objective out of many. Maximizing shareholder value is not a managerial obligation, it is a managerial choice.”


So when presented with a choice between taking even a high price for the company’s shares or protecting the income and jobs of their employees, protecting the businesses of their local vendors and supplier, protecting the livelihood of many, many other local businesses that live off the spending generated by the company’s payrolls, investing in state of the art capital for long run sustainable economic performance, investing in the quality of life of the local citizenry in the form of education and cultural facilities, the board of directors should not  have taken the excuse of law or regulation. They should have remembered that their responsibilities lie not to the wealth of their shareholders, but to the long run benefit of the corporation. They should have shown more steel themselves and struck a much, much better bargain for the corporation. 

Location: Blogs Parent Separator The Discussion

60 comment(s) so far...

Online Cake Delivery

You can also buy all flavors cakes from here with free home delivery.
Midnight Cake Delivery
Birthday Cake Delivery in Noida
Valentine Flowers

By Online Cake Delivery on   11/27/2016 10:55 PM

Re: How Wall Street Bent Steel

Occasions Made Special with Online Cake Delivery at Midnight.
Online Cake in Delhi
Online Cake in Noida
Online Cake in Faridabad

By Online Cake Delivery on   11/27/2016 10:56 PM

Online Cake Delivery

Enjoy the best cakes delivery in the comfort of your home.
Birthday Cake Delivery in Gurgaon
Valentines Day Gifts 2017

By Online Cake Delivery on   11/27/2016 10:56 PM

Online Cake Blog

Sweet as the Moment When the On the Cakengift Cake & Flower Services:-

By Online Cake Blog on   1/7/2017 4:29 AM

Order Cake in Delivery Blog

A Smooth-Running On the Cakengift Cake & Flower & Cake Services:-

By Order Cake in Delivery Blog on   1/7/2017 4:33 AM

Re: How Wall Street Bent Steel

Hurrah! At last I got a website from where I know how to truly obtain helpful data concerning my study and knowledge.

By Female Call Girls in Delhi on   1/31/2017 1:44 AM

Re: How Wall Street Bent Steel

Hi admin
I examine your blog it provides amazing information and i enjoyed reading this post. daily latest news in urdu
You can see all the latest urdu news i hope u will visit

By daily latest urdu news on   5/25/2017 12:24 PM

Re: How Wall Street Bent Steel

Glad to see your post, and hope things improve so we get some more posts to read!

By Ayesha on   6/15/2017 12:19 AM

Re: How Wall Street Bent Steel

Howdy, Very amazing, We exchange an inclination the surprising Partners in Delhi, who work Independently and give the high-class satisfaction to clients.

By Surbhi Gupta on   6/27/2017 5:24 AM


Sensible post!..good information,it is genuinely truly reestablished me an extraordinary arrangement and i on a to a striking degree basic level prized it.Thanks for posting such an illuminating substance. | | | |

By Ritu Singh on   6/27/2017 5:25 AM

Re: How Wall Street Bent Steel

This blog says in regards to news surveys on ardent advanced organization. The subtle elements I have find from this blog to get numerous open doors and directions. These are altogether expected to more directions to every one of us.

By daily latest news in urdu on   7/6/2017 1:57 PM

Re: How Wall Street Bent Steel

Debilitated return here routinely to perceive what is new an obligation of appreciation is all together for these extraordinary upgrades! Well what to expect at 6 week ultrasound this is difficult one to search on but website includes every thing out here.

By what to expect at 6 week ultrasound on   7/6/2017 2:01 PM


Was very good post
,انجام پروژه با متلب متلبی , , ,پروژه متلب , ,پروژه متلب ,
شبیه سازی با متلب انجام پروژه دانشجویی , شبیه سازی با Matlab , پروژه متلب , پروژه Matlab , متلب , انجام پروژه متلب , پروژه آماده متلب
شبیه سازی با متلب
پروژه متلب
انجام پروژه متلب
پروژه متلب
سفارش پروژه متلب
شبیه سازی با Matlab
پروژه متلب
پروژه Matlab
پروژه متلب
شبیه سازی Matlab
project Matlab
[url=http://]matlab project[/url]
[url=]پروژه مطلب[/url]
[url=]پروژه متلب[/url]
[url=]پروژه متلب[/url]
[url=http://]انجام پروژه متلب[/url]

By پروژه متلب on   7/8/2017 6:06 AM


Thankful to you for pulling in us to respond this site. Ideally this site winds up conspicuously more unmistakable and clear for others. thanks for sharing thsi post with us. | | | |

By Nisha Roy on   8/7/2017 12:41 AM

Female Escorts Services in Gurgaon

awesome publish. i used to be confirming often your weblog site web page net web page and i’m inspired! Very valuable information specifically the ultimate element 🙂 I take care of within the equivalent way research a lot. i was looking out this sure information for many years. thank you and awesome of lot of coins.

By Anta Kusuma on   8/10/2017 5:14 AM

Aerocity Call Girls
Details concerning the optimal/optimally escort services can be gotten through various reviews. All and any actions which take

By aerocity Call Girls on   8/10/2017 8:11 AM

Re: How Wall Street Bent Steel

Delhi Escorts
Zarina is a Delhi Escorts Service provider website. It is a website who gives you perfect relaxation moments of your busiest and exhausted life which is always alive

By Delhi Escorts on   8/10/2017 8:15 AM

Re: How Wall Street Bent Steel

you're truly a decent website admin. The site stacking speed is unimaginable. It appears that you are doing any interesting trap. What's more, The substance is masterwork. you've made an incredible showing with regards to on this theme!

By I am broken on   8/18/2017 7:58 AM

The sequential falling of two waves will make hubs where the recurrence will be zero. The ROADMs has given the choice to change the recurrence physically. To get it naturally it needs to take after Aussie paper which has the prompts do it.

By latest international urdu news on   8/18/2017 7:59 AM


Packers and movers in thane@
Packers and movers in varanasi@
Packers and movers in surat@
Packers and movers in lucknow@

By KANHAIYA on   8/20/2017 10:46 PM

Hylix oil is one of the best

Hylix oil is one of the best hair loss herbal remedies to prevent dandruff problem in men and women in a safe manner.

By gostream on   8/24/2017 9:16 AM

Delhi Escorts
Zarina is a Delhi Escorts Service provider website. It is a website who gives you perfect relaxation moments of your busiest and exhausted life which is always alive

By Delhi Escorts on   8/26/2017 7:30 AM

Aerocity Call Girls The escorts offer a package to their clients including immense of services. Aerocity Escorts is among the top association

By Aerocity Call Girls on   8/26/2017 7:32 AM

Re: How Wall Street Bent Steel

I am a straightforward Guy who is chipping away at couple of sites. In this way, here i will inform you regarding games and the one game is scrabble run free online which is an instructive game for kids. Youngsters can play pogo scrabble for fun as well as to learn new words. Nonetheless, Scrabble Dictionary is not accessible on my locales but rather you can mess around with Scrabble Sprint game.

By Free Online on   9/3/2017 11:03 AM

Re: How Wall Street Bent Steel

Hey there, I’m Senja. I’m a doctor living in Surabaya, Indonesia.
I am a fan of poker online, bandar togel, and gaming. I’m also interested in soccer and sports.
You can visit my website with a click on the button above.

Poker Online
Bandar Togel
Judi Bola

By poker online terpercaya on   9/6/2017 11:35 PM

Re: How Wall Street Bent Steel

your Gifted with talent Now you are proving that

Bandar Togel
href="" poker online
href="" poker online terpercaya
href="" judi online
href="" poker online uang asli
href="" domino online
href="" judi poker
href="" jackpot terbesar
situs judi online
Bandar Bola
judi togel
keluaran togel Singapore
result togel Singapore
togel online
Domino Online
Casino online
judi bola
taruhan bola

By taruhan bola on   9/6/2017 11:37 PM

Re: How Wall Street Bent Steel

I must say you had done a tremendous job,I appreciate all your efforts.
Thanks alot for your writings.
Waiting for a new 1...Please visit our wonderful and valuable website-
For More Details Visit are Official Websites :
taruhan bola
href="" poker online terpercaya
Bandar Togel

By taruhan bola on   9/6/2017 11:37 PM


Hi, Very awesome, your article and blog. This is best article. when I read your article more data one of other blog section. So I like it. Much appreciation to you for offering this article to us.

By Minna on   9/9/2017 2:51 AM

Best Service

I look at this Blog I am unbelievably Grateful to get this spread here. You should get this pass on online I am all around Happy to talk about this appreciative.

By Inspiracion on   9/9/2017 2:51 AM


Howdy Guys! We are redesigning Wonderful data about reservation your favored nearest sidekick more enthusiastic young ladies and we will equip you with the most quieting accomplices.

By Inspiracion on   9/12/2017 4:41 AM

Re: How Wall Street Bent Steel

I like your all post. You have done really good work. Thank you for the information you provide, it helped me a lot.
I hope to have many more entries or so from you.
href="" Poker online uang asli
href="" Judi poker terpercaya
href="" promo bonus new member
href="" jackpot terbesar
href="" situs poker online

By POKER ONLINE UANG ASLI on   9/23/2017 11:11 PM

Re: How Wall Street Bent Steel

poker online indonesia
bandar togel terpercaya
taruhan bola online

By poker online indonesia on   10/4/2017 3:16 AM

Escorts in Gurgaon Service

Gurgaon Escorts
Escorts in Gurgaonis one of the most colorful and cultural city of Call Girl in Gurgaon and since it is the capital city, providing ample opportunities Gurgaon Escort Service for various sectors including jobs, is a must here. Female Escorts in Gurgaon There are numerous good universities here which attracts students from all over the world and apart from that it is also emerging as one of the peaceful and safest city to work in. Independent Escorts in GurgaonLooking at all these parameters, many people come to this city with a dream and most of them are able to achieve them with some efforts.
Escorts in Gurgaon Service

By Gurgaon Escorts on   10/5/2017 1:12 AM

Re: How Wall Street Bent Steel

termite protection

By Daphne on   11/2/2017 11:11 AM

Re: How Wall Street Bent Steel

Most of the posts are now not unique, but your article is really unique and very helpful. Thanks.

By Mahi on   11/4/2017 11:34 AM

Tour packages

I should state you had done a huge job,I welcome every one of your endeavors.
Much obliged alot for your works.

By pakistan tour packages on   11/7/2017 3:20 AM

Re: How Wall Street Bent Steel

cctv surveillance system

By best surveillance equipments in delhi on   11/8/2017 2:57 AM

cctv surveillance system

By CCTV on   11/23/2017 2:10 PM

cashew nuts supplier in Dubai

I am delighted to see this post.Thank you for Sharing!
cashew nuts supplier in dubai
A4 paper supplier in dubai
onion supplier in dubai
potato supplier in dubai
spices&grains supplier in dubai

By Fuzzy Internatiopnal on   11/29/2017 2:12 AM

Escorts Service Fairway

Call Girls In Golf Course Road

By Nirmala Escorts on   12/5/2017 3:13 AM

Re: How Wall Street Bent Steel

I am truly very happy with this website because this website gives us always latest institute information, which is very helpful for me, Thanks for your best explanation and effort which you saw in your post.
Coupons Codes

By Jhon Smith on   12/13/2017 3:53 AM

andheri escorts

We Offers an Independent Andheri Escorts can be the motivation to making you cheerful, and she is likewise accessible for your private gatherings and different events. Andheri Escort Service

By andheri escorts on   12/19/2017 5:12 AM

Re: How Wall Street Bent Steel

his post is truly inspiring. I like your post and everything you share with us is current and very informative, I want to bookmark the page so I can return here from you that you have done a fantastic job. Female Escorts Services in Gurgaon
Affordable Escorts Services in Gurgaon

By Anjali on   12/21/2017 12:31 AM

Re: How Wall Street Bent Steel

A debt of gratitude is in order for sharing so implication article with us. I concur with your thought completely.I am anticipating another awesome article from you.

By Ajay Bhati on   1/9/2018 11:34 AM

Re: How Wall Street Bent Steel

Congratulation for your new achievements and go ahead .. thanks for it

By Shivani Bhatt on   1/14/2018 11:25 PM

Re: How Wall Street Bent Steel

This is really amazing Post I really love to read your post. Thanks for share.
seo training in delhi
laptop repairing institutes
mobile repairing courses in delhi
career growth in digital marketing

By Naina Bose on   1/19/2018 12:47 AM

Re: How Wall Street Bent Steel

I've been looking out for this equivalent type of post for previous a week and infrequently got here throughout this. Thanks very much and will look for extra postings from you.

By free online movies on   1/20/2018 8:08 AM

Your name:
Your website:
Add Comment   Cancel 
© Copyright 2011 - 2018 University of Denver, Daniels College of Business. All Rights Reserved.
Rock Solid Design